A Time for Mercy by
John Grisham
My rating:
4 of 5 stars
Poor Jake he is facing bankruptcy again and an unpopular case (this time he gets severely beaten by the victims family)
I enjoyed the book but it highlights several problems with Mississippi Laws.
First there is the automatic "death penalty" attached to the case just because the POS victim happened to work as a police officer. His death was in no way related to his job as a deputy, and his occupation shouldn't have been an issue and the death penalty shouldn't have even been an option. The POS Stuart Kofer was shot because he was a drunken bully who routinely got drunk and beat up his girlfriend and her children and threatened to kill them. The night he died he has beaten the Mother, Josie, so badly that she was unconscious and her children Drew (age 16) and Kiera (age 14) believed her to be dead. After knocking Josie out he preceded upstairs to Kiera's bedroom and tried to break the door down to get to her (we later learn that he had been raping her and threatened to kill her family and her if she told anyone). Stu eventually goes to bed and Drew scared of what Stu will do if he wakes up takes Stu's service revolver and shoots him when he seems to be stirring. THIS SHOULD HAVE BEEN VIEWED AS SELF DEFENSE BUT THE POLICE ACT LIKE STU WAS SOME HERO SHOT DOWN IN THE LINE OF DUTY.
None of the local lawyers want to take the case so Judge Noose forces it on Jake Brigance. Besides it being an unpopular case causing lots of hard feelings in the community there is a law on the books capping the attorney fee. Noose's scheme to make sure that Jake gets paid a fair amount backfires when the Board of Supervisors appeal Noose's ruling.
At the end of the book the jury is tied 6-6 and a mistrial is declared. But unfortunately there is no limit to how many times someone can be indicted for the same crime. So Drew is facing another trial for the same crime, this seems really unfair and his entire life can be hijacked by this. Kira gives birth to Stu's baby and the Brigance's adopt the boy who they name Lucian (although he'll be called Luke).
View all my reviews