The Which Way Tree by
Elizabeth Crook
My rating:
3 of 5 stars
Book Club Questions and Answers
Did you enjoy The Which Way Tree... why or why not?
To some extent I did enjoy it, I was troubled by the mistreatment of the animals in the book.
Benjamin mentions Moby Dick throughout the book. Do you see parallels between Ahab and Samantha in their quest for revenge against the animals that maimed them? Are there any other parallels with other stories of quests for revenge that you can think of?
I did see parallels to Moby Dick, although I found the frequent mentions of Moby Dick tiresome.
What did you think of the format of the book-- that it was composed of letters? What were the advantages of this format and what, if any, the disadvantages?
I disliked it as I prefer books where you feel you are part of the story. Reading this as something that happened in the past lessened it's impact for me. The advantage from my point of view was it allowed us to find out what happened to Sam and Benjamin after the story ended.
What did you think of the ending of the book? What did you think happened to Samantha? Why do you feel she left the hide behind?
I think she realized the hide didn't make her happy. Unless she found a way to change I am afraid she meet a bad end. Her bad attitude lead her into a lot of dangerous situations and caused a lot of conflict.
Before you read this book, were you aware that many of the Germans in Texas were on the side of the Union and killed or harassed by the Sesesh (Confederates)? Did it change your perceptions on the Civil War in any way?
I had never heard the term Sesesh before reading this book. I found it to be an interesting glimpse into this period of Texas' history. But it didn't really change my perceptions of the Civil War.
Did you think Hanlin was as well-developed a character as the others or did you find him one dimensional?
He didn't have any redeeming qualities and I thought drowning was too good for him after he shot his Uncle's horse.
We find out that Pacheco is out for the bounty on the panther in order to rebuild his ranch. Why do you think Preacher Dob went along?
I think it was a mixture of wanting to keep an eye on his dog and the children and a chance to go on an adventure that he could feel good about. The panther was raiding livestock and attacking people so he could feel like he was benefiting people by helping to track it down.
Why do you think Samantha is so determined to kill the panther? Did you find her determination to exact revenge admirable or foolhardy?
I found it disturbing, I really think she needed psychiatric help.
When Benjamin starts the story, it doesn't seem that he likes his stepmother, Juda, at all. Why do you think that was and do you think it later colors his feelings towards Samantha?
I think he resented her taking his Mother's place and she was really strict and seemed to favor her own daughter over Benjamin. I don't think it colors his feelings toward Samantha, in fact he seemed to appreciate Juda's cleaning after she was dead and wished Sam was more like her.
Is there a character you identified with and why? No, but I would have liked to have read more about Zechariah (the dog) and Pacheco and his horse.
View all my reviews